Why Do Black Families Eat Mac & Cheese On Thanksgiving? The History Behind The Tradition

For many Black families, Thanksgiving simply wouldn’t be complete without a decadent dish of macaroni and cheese on the table. We’re talking about the golden, crispy top layer, the creamy noodles underneath, and, of course, that unforgettable cheese pull with every serving. It’s the kind of dish that brings comfort, flavor, and a whole lot of soul to the holiday dinner table. But while mac and cheese is undeniably delicious, there’s a much deeper story behind why it holds such a special place in Black Thanksgiving traditions. Between those cheesy layers is a history that blends enslaved culinary innovation, celebration, abundance, and generations of family traditions.
And to understand how mac and cheese became a holiday staple, we have to take a trip back to the 18th century and recognize one of the chefs whose influence helped shape American cuisine: James Hemings.
Who was James Hemings?
Hemings, an enslaved African American chef who trained in France while enslaved by Thomas Jefferson, is widely credited with helping introduce and popularize French-inspired macaroni dishes in America. Born in 1765 to Elizabeth Hemings, an enslaved woman who worked for the wealthy Wayles family in Virginia, James was also Jefferson’s brother-in-law and enslaved property, according to The Jefferson Monticello website.
Despite the oppressive circumstances of his life, Hemings developed an extraordinary culinary skill set. He received formal training in Paris, where he worked in prestigious kitchens and learned the art of French cooking. His culinary education included classic dishes such as crème brûlée, along with the techniques behind French breads, meringue, and other baked goods, according to the documentary The Man Who Cooked for Presidents. But his macaroni dish was a hit. According to the New England Culinary Arts Training Instagram page, Hemings made his macaroni from scratch with sharp cheddar, Parmesan, and butter for a rich, creamy, cheesy finish.
When Hemings returned to the United States in late 1789, he brought that culinary knowledge with him. His training introduced new French cooking methods and European dishes into Jefferson’s households in New York, Philadelphia, and Virginia, including his macaroni and cheese, bringing the dish into the American culinary conversation. He also became known for a dish called “snow eggs,” which were “puffs of meringue poached in milk syrup and served chilled over English custard,” according to NPR writer Maria Godoy. The Jefferson family would go on to preserve the dish over generations.
While serving as head chef at Monticello, Jefferson’s primary home located near Charlottesville, Virginia, he prepared elaborate meals and expanded the household’s culinary tastes, eventually training his brother Peter to take over the kitchen before securing his own emancipation in 1796.
But while Hemings’ contributions helped establish macaroni dishes in early American cuisine, the story of mac and cheese doesn’t end in the kitchens of wealthy white households. Its evolution into the beloved comfort food we recognize today is also deeply connected to the contributions of Black cooks across the U.S.
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Angry
0
Sad
0
Wow
0