Why Does The Trump Administration Have ICE Going Through Our Stuff?

There was a time when Americans could reasonably assume that registering to vote was an ordinary act of citizenship, not an invitation for the federal government to start snooping around their lives.

Under Donald Trump, apparently, those days are over.

Immigration and Customs Enforcement has morphed from an agency charged with enforcing immigration laws into something far more dangerous: a heavily armed, increasingly unaccountable surveillance operation serving a president who has never met a democratic institution he didn’t want to bully, bend or break.

Trump’s personal Gestapo is no longer just about rounding up immigrants (whether in the country legally or not). It’s about building a government with the technological firepower to find people, track them, investigate them, and make them think twice about exercising their constitutional rights.

And now, that machinery is getting tangled up in Americans’ right to vote.

A WIRED investigation revealed that ICE’s investigative division obtained tens of millions of voter records and explored incorporating voter data into Palantir’s ELITE system, a tool designed to help identify and locate people targeted for deportation. WIRED reported that Palantir said voter-roll data had not actually been integrated into ELITE.

Let that sink in. The agency tasked with hunting immigrants was exploring how to incorporate voter information into a system used to find people for deportation enforcement. According to Democracy Docket’s reporting on records obtained through a public-records lawsuit, ICE collected tens of millions of voter records as part of its investigation into alleged election fraud. Officials also explored investigations involving nonprofit organizations that register voters.

The administration says it’s looking for election fraud. Fine. Investigate actual crimes. Nobody is arguing that noncitizens should be allowed to vote in federal elections. But there’s a difference between investigating credible evidence of a crime and building a massive surveillance operation around the people who participate in democracy.

And here’s the thing: There is no credible evidence of some massive army of undocumented immigrants stealing American elections. There are documented cases of a handful of people breaking the law, which is not evidence of some grand conspiracy to overthrow American democracy.

In fact, the Brennan Center for Justice’s research review reports that a 2016 survey of election officials across 42 jurisdictions, covering 23.5 million votes, identified just 30 (you read that correctly, 30, as in 3-0) suspected noncitizen-voting incidents referred for further investigation. And that was merely 30 suspicions, not 30 proven cases.

That’s not proof that election fraud never happens. It’s proof that the evidence doesn’t come close to matching the panic. Republicans love to wave around individual cases like they’ve stumbled upon the smoking gun in a murder mystery. Look! Seven people! A dozen cases! Somebody call the FBI! But when you actually examine the evidence, the supposed epidemic starts looking a whole lot more like a political talking point in search of a crisis.

And now we’re supposed to believe the appropriate response is to let ICE rummage through millions of Americans’ voter records, cross-reference them with immigration databases and potentially feed that information into systems built to track people for deportation?

Come on.

ICE’s surveillance capabilities already extend well beyond voter records. WIRED reported on allegations that ICE collected photographs, license-plate numbers and other information about people observing immigration enforcement. The Department of Homeland Security disputed the characterization of the case. But the allegations illustrate the very real concern that surveillance tools can be turned toward people who are watching the government, rather than committing crimes themselves.

Now imagine the effect of federal immigration agents showing up around a polling place.

The possibility of ICE appearing at voting locations has become a concern for election officials and civil rights groups ahead of the midterms. WIRED has reported on election officials preparing for the possibility of ICE showing up at the polls, while the Washington Post has covered legal efforts to prevent federal agents from intimidating voters.

The point isn’t that every federal agent at an election site proves a coordinated intimidation campaign. It’s that the presence of armed immigration officers, combined with aggressive voter-data collection, can make people wonder whether exercising their rights could put them under government scrutiny.

For immigrant communities, mixed-status families and naturalized citizens, that fear can be especially potent. A person doesn’t have to be doing anything wrong to worry about being questioned, misidentified, or investigated.

And the administration’s voter-roll crusade has already run into the law. On Oct. 9, a federal judge ruled unlawful the Justice Department’s policy of obtaining state voter rolls and cross-checking them against federal immigration records. Reuters reported on the ruling, which underscores that the government cannot simply invent new powers because the president declares something a priority.

If Republicans have evidence of widespread noncitizen voting, let’s see it. Show us the numbers. Show us the convictions. Show us the massive operation supposedly threatening American elections.

Because the evidence supports a much less dramatic conclusion: noncitizen voting is a real but rare problem, while the government’s appetite for collecting personal information is getting awfully big.

And somehow, we’re supposed to believe the threat to democracy is the immigrant who might cast an illegal ballot—not the government building a surveillance machine that could put millions of legitimate voters under suspicion.

That’s why ICE has become Trump’s Gestapo. The danger isn’t that America has become Nazi Germany. It’s that a government agency is accumulating the tools, secrecy and political permission to treat ordinary people as targets first and citizens with rights second.

ICE doesn’t need to know how you voted. It doesn’t need to turn the polling place into an extension of its surveillance operation. And Trump’s obsession with election fraud doesn’t give his administration permission to treat every voter like a suspect.

The right to vote isn’t a privilege bestowed by Donald Trump. It’s a right that belongs to the people.

If this administration can’t understand the difference, the rest of us had better defend that right before the machinery built to frighten immigrants becomes a tool for frightening everybody else.

SEE ALSO:

Latest Trump Election Tantrum: Lawsuit To Toss California Mail Ballots

Todd Blanche Gets Testy Defending Trump Election Interference Lawsuit