It Is Not A Flex To Keep Saying That Black Women Are ‘Saving Democracy’

Nov 16, 2026 - 16:00
 0  1
It Is Not A Flex To Keep Saying That Black Women Are ‘Saving Democracy’
I Voted Today
Source: LPETTET / Getty

If the headlines are to be believed, for six straight years, Black women have apparently been saving American democracy from the consequences of white America’s political decisions and conditions we did not create.

White voters can keep voting against their own interests; they can keep supporting authoritarianism, racism, xenophobia, and somehow the headlines praise Black women for showing up in sufficient numbers to stop this country from going to hell.

Let’s recap, shall we?

Back in November 2020, writing for The Washington Post, Taylor Crumpton told us, “Black women saved the Democrats. Don’t make us do it again.”  A perfectly reasonable request that, as subsequent elections have demonstrated, went largely ignored, and here we are again.

Opinion writer Karen Attiah was equally blunt in her Washington Post piece, “America calls on Kamala Harris — and Black women — to clean up its mess.” The irony, of course, is that less than five years after publishing her warning, the paper demonstrated how racist institutions treat Black women by firing her for her remarks on social media about the killing of Charlie Kirk. 

At that time, Feminista Jones asked in The Philadelphia Inquirer, “Black women saved democracy yet again. Where’s our moment of gratitude?” Well, apparently it arrived right on schedule, according to DeMario P. Smith over at Blavity, who declared, “There’s Finally A Wave Of Gratitude For Black Women And It’s Because Of The 2020 Election.” 

How generous that after centuries of slavery, racial terror, and political disfranchisement, Black women had finally earned ourselves a national thanks-sis, note. And the applause kept coming about how Black women fought to mobilize America’s voters and how Black feminists taught Democrats to “win big.”  

So, Black women apparently cleaned up America’s mess, and we earned the nation’s gratitude. And then, after the confetti settled, the country promptly resumed its centuries-long tradition of showing irreparable contempt for our lives, with all measurable indices on health, wealth, employment and human well-being proving just how little that gratitude was worth.

Now, flash forward to 2026. 

Apparently this battered republic near-bout up and died again, and needed to be rescued. Summon our dusky sisters because democracy has once again collapsed upon its musty colonial fainting couch. And right on cue, the post-election ritual headlines came back, full of hosannas to Black women’s political heroism.

Van Jones: “HOW BLACK WOMEN SAVED AMERICA. TheGrio: “Black women once again understood the assignment” and “‘Black women are not waiting for history to happen’: The 2026 Midterm elections prove it.”  COURIER: “Black Women Carried the Wave. The Bill Is Due.” NBC Washington: “How Black women helped create the midterm ‘blue wave.’” The Boston Globe: “How to ‘thank’ Black women for their midterms vote.” Social media was also overflowing with praise for how Black women had once again carried democracy on our shoulders.

So, in 2020, the question was, where are the thanks to Black women? Then we’d finally been thanked, and now six years later, we’re getting instructions on how to thank Black women. So many stages of gratitude.

Last week, as the final votes were counted in Mississippi and Scott Colom made history as the state’s first Black U.S. senator elected in 145 years, Black women’s voting power was rediscovered again. The exit poll numbers reported that 99% of Black women, who constituted roughly 20% of the electorate, voted for Colom, compared with 96% of Black men, 33% of white women, and 21% of white men. 

Yes, Black women’s votes absolutely mattered. But after every election cycle, I find myself asking the same set of questions: Are Black women really saving democracy?  What, exactly, are we saving?  Given this country’s racist, bloody history, why would we want to save democracy? And what have Black women received for their loyalty and for carrying this civic burden?

As Democrats rode a blue wave through the midterms, the national polls showed that 93% of Black women backed the party’s candidates. That number was not extraordinary because Black women have been among the Democratic Party’s most reliable voting blocs. In 2024, 92% of Black women voted for Kamala Harris, 90% supported Joe Biden in 2020, and Hillary Clinton got 94% of the Black women vote in 2016.  All this political labor and language about “saving democracy” should not be mistaken for political power because it conveniently obscures the fact that there’s a difference between being indispensable to winning elections and having the power to shape policies and material conditions after them.

Let’s keep it real: Black women “showed up and showed out” and “understood the assignment” for six straight years, but did any of that save Black women from the Trump regime’s economic bloodletting of the past two years?  Have we been able to reclaim more than 251,000 jobs lost between January and August 2025 alone, or the roughly 95,000 federal jobs?

Has voting overwhelmingly for the Democrats given Black women as a voting bloc control over legislation, federal agencies, courts, employers, or state governments?  How’s our employment security? Have our ballots saved DEI, or Black history from being scrubbed from every damn where?  What about our civil rights protections? How are we doing in the maternity wards? How are we navigating disproportionate barriers to reproductive autonomy? What about our access to affordable health insurance? Have we decreased our poverty rates?  

Have we saved our children from the conditions under which they are expected to survive, learn, and grow up?

We’ve saved democracy, but have we purged our communities of lead-contaminated drinking water, neurotoxic air pollutants, and the environmental hazards poisoning our neighborhoods? Have we saved our schools from chronic underfunding, racist teachers who keep dumbing down, suspending, expelling, and criminalizing our children? We’ve saved democracy but tell me why cops and vigilantes keep brutalizing and killing our sons, including infants? 

Tell me, what good is being celebrated for saving democracy when Black women are still being asked to celebrate the survival of a democracy that has yet to guarantee our own?

So forgive me if I’m not exactly feeling particularly heroic because there’s something historically dishonest about describing American democracy as if it has been some kind of pure political institution from which Black women, and all other marginalized groups, have only been temporarily excluded for hundreds of years. 

And why exactly would we want to “save” democracy?  Save it from what exactly? Its own evil history? 

If you understand that American democracy, I mean really understand how it was constructed on the foundation of Indigenous genocide and land dispossession, sustained by the enslavement of millions of Africans, and then perfected through centuries of racial exclusion, exploitation, murder, carceral systems, and state-sanctioned violence, then why would you want to save democracy? Anyone with a serious understanding of that history knows that democracy in this country has never been an innocent institution periodically contaminated by forces alien to its founding principles. 

Folks need to distinguish between democracy as an emancipatory political ideal and America’s long project of racial domination. The Black freedom struggle has never simply been about saving American democracy, but about forcing it to become something fundamentally different and more just from what its architects intended. 

So when Black women are summoned, yet again, to “save democracy,” we must seriously ask: are we being celebrated for expanding its promises?  Or are Black women being conscripted into preserving a political order and saving from the consequences of its own depravity? Black people have spent centuries dragging this country kicking and screaming toward a democracy it never intended to become. And every time we wrench some measure of progress from America’s clenched fists, it devises some new, vicious way to knock the hell out of us.

I dunno, Y’all. Maybe we have to rethink what “saving democracy” really means. Maybe it means we’ve been preserving just enough political space for marginalized people to continue fighting for some glorious, perpetually postponed future in which America finally becomes the egalitarian society it has spent centuries pretending it already is. Or, maybe we’re out here trying to save the possibility that tomorrow’s America might be less cruel than it is today.

Now if you put it that way, then Black women, who are extraordinary politically conscious, aren’t often voting loyally but defensively because we understand that we are forced to choose between a political party that routinely captures our votes and frequently disappoints us, and a nasty political movement whose policies threaten to strangle the hell out of us every which way.  So our votes are triage.

And at the end of the day, maybe that’s why the “Black women saved democracy” narrative has been so chronically irresistible. It serves multiple functions: Democrats get to praise us without producing policies that materially reward us. White liberals get to thank us without confronting the racist white folks threatening it, including those in their own families. And it allows Black women’s demands to remain ignored while serving as endlessly renewable political infrastructure.

Now, some of you might rightly be asking: Well, what the hell do you think would happen if Black women disappeared entirely from the electorate? 

Yes, the Democratic coalition would unquestionably be weaker, and a number of candidates would have lost races, but we should be careful about making a rhetorical leap that Black women’s votes single-handedly produced the blue wave. In fact, the Mississippi Senate race was decided by less than a percentage point, so removing that constituency would have obviously transformed the electoral math. But there’s also evidence that Democrats still would have led the national House vote by roughly eight points. While Black women provided the strongest Democratic support, the swing that produced the blue wave also came from changes among other groups, including white women, younger voters, Hispanic voters and moderates. 

But remember, being indispensable to a political coalition ain’t the same as “saving democracy.” Black women consistently vote the way we want to protect our interests, rights, families, communities, and Black futures. Our ordinary political agency is not “saving democracy” or some kind of racialized civic obligation.

I want us to start thinking about how we direct our political power not toward preserving American empire, but toward building a post-imperial future where our children are not treated as disposable, our labor is not endlessly extracted, our bodies are not sites of state violence, our communities are not laboratories for poison and punishment, and our economic security does not depend on the benevolence of institutions that have historically profited from our vulnerability.

What we need to be measuring Black political success by how many Black children survive to adulthood, how many Black families can afford homes, how many Black mothers survive childbirth, how many Black lives we can protect from state carceral systems and murder, how much wealth remains in our communities, and how much control we exercise over the institutions governing our lives.

Black women have spent generations alongside Black men fighting to wrest freedom from a country that built its democracy on denying us that inalienable right. The next chapter of our political imagination should be about something far more consequential than saving America from itself. Because I, for one, am considerably more interested in saving Black lives and future prospects than I am in preserving a racist republic that keeps congratulating us for surviving its cruelties while using our political participation as consent or endorsement of the very system we’ve been struggling to change for centuries.

SEE ALSO:

Nicki Minaj Campaigned For Trump, Who Told America To Look At Her Ass

Of Course America Justified The Police Killing Of A Black Baby [Op-Ed]

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Angry Angry 0
Sad Sad 0
Wow Wow 0